Bat Hibernacula Passing the Test

A hibernation site under construction at BiodiversityWorks.

Our collaborative endangered bat research discovered a new behavior in northern long-eared bats (Myotis septentrionalis) on Martha’s Vineyard, Nantucket, and Long Island 2016 – 2018. We found them hibernating in crawl spaces and unfinished cinder block basements under older homes (Dowling and O’Dell 2018, Hoff et al. 2024). Prior to this work, bat biologists thought that all northern long-eared bats migrated to the mainland to hibernate in caves and mines. Learning that they were hibernating locally was astounding, especially because the species was persisting on the islands amidst the white-nose syndrome crisis that had killed millions of bats in the Northeast. However, many older homes on these islands were being demolished and replaced with new energy efficient houses that don’t accommodate bats under the structure. To address this winter housing crisis for these endangered bats, we received a U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service White-nose Syndrome Research for Conservation Grant in 2022 to build and test designs for bat hibernacula on these islands. In the fall of 2022, we constructed an underground bat hibernation site (hibernaculum) adjacent to our headquarters using a design by Carl Herzog (retired NY DEC). We also modified two other existing structures on Martha’s Vineyard, and Nantucket Conservation Foundation modified an old foundation on Nantucket.

An acoustic lure ready to broadcast bat calls to attract bats while a camera on the entrance grate is set to capture images of bats entering or exiting the hibernation site.

The next phase of our work was to lure northern long-eared bats to our newly constructed (BWorks HQ) and modified (Batz Carlton, Jones Cave, and Nantucket) bat hibernacula. Playing northern long-eared bat greatest hits calls, curated by Dr. Samantha Hoff (a partner on our project), we ran lures in fall 2023 and are currently running them again this fall. We play the lures for four hours after sunset for 14 nights at each site. We target warm nights with little or no wind. We placed an acoustic detector inside and outside each hibernaculum to record bat calls, and they are set to begin recording when the acoustic lures stop broadcasting. To regularly monitor temperature and humidity inside each hibernaculum, we installed HOBO data loggers. A camera at the entrance grate was also installed to document any bats entering or exiting each site.

From fall 2023 to spring 2024, our cameras did not capture images of any bats entering or exiting the hibernacula. Over the spring and summer of 2024, Dr. Hoff reviewed all of the acoustic data (many thousand bat acoustic files) from detectors inside and outside each hibernaculum. The good news was that all hibernacula had northern long-eared bat activity recorded on the detector outside the entrance in the fall. This means that they were attracted to the hibernation site and investigated it. The detectors we used inside the hibernacula used a different microphone, and the files it produced were not as high quality. However, Dr. Hoff was able to confirm big brown or eastern red bats inside the BiodiversityWorks HQ hibernaculum in October, November, December, and March. There was potentially a northern long-eared bat inside the Jones cave, but the calls were not 100% clear. A check of the data loggers showed the hibernacula humidity remained high and temperatures stable despite outside temperature fluctuations. Thus, the hibernacula passed the test for offering ideal hibernation conditions. With the acoustic data indicating bat interest and occupancy at the hibernacula, and the stable environment within the hibernacula over the winter, we know we are on the right track. The Nantucket bat cave did not attract any bats from fall 2023 through spring 2024, but we have hope for this fall and winter. Bats are creatures of habit when it comes to favored roost sites, summer or winter. So it can take a few years for them to occupy a new site.

Liz Olson handing a UV light down to a technician to set it and clean the site of Pd fungus.

An important piece of this research is to make sure we are creating a safe space for bats to hibernate where they can survive infection with the fungus Pseudogymnoascus destructans (Pd), which causes white-nose syndrome (WNS). Both northern long-eared and little brown bat (Myotis lucifugus) populations plummeted after the fungus was accidentally introduced to North America from Europe in 2006. Little brown bats are demonstrating better resilience and recovery than northerns, but northerns are persisting in small numbers coastal areas. We believe this is because their WNS infection period is shorter due to milder winters in coastal environments where they are hibernating in or under anthropogenic structures. The Pd fungus thrives in the cool, damp, humid spaces where hibernating bats spend the winter. When bats move between hibernation sites, which they often do, they move the fungus with them. The fungus has rapidly spread across North America (see the spread map here). If infected bats survive the winter, they can clear themselves of the fungus after they emerge from hibernation. Once they become active and start feeding, their immune systems become active against the fungal infection. They also shift their roost preferences to warm and dry places during the spring and summer, which limits the fungal growth. However, bats can be re-infected by the fungus when they return to the damp, cool hibernation sites where the fungus persists year-round.

Because we had bat activity at our new hibernacula, and the bats could have brought Pd fungus spores with them, we needed to ‘clean’ the hibernacula prior to the 2024/2025 hibernation season. We treated each hibernaculum with ultraviolet (UV) light to kill any fungus inside. UV lights are used to quickly sanitize hospital rooms and other commercial settings. Bat biologists had tested this method and found it is an effective way to clear more than 95% of Pd in experimental settings. The UV exposure goal for Pd is a minimum of 10 miliJoules per square centimeter for the 254 nm wavelength UV lights we are using, so we set our limit at 15 mj of exposure and measured the area of exposure for our light using dosimetry cards. We systematically moved the UV light around the hibernacula ensuring all crevices and corners were exposed for the appropriate amount of time (15 minutes for each area).

A speaker on the roof of the headquarters is set to broadcast bat calls into the air above the hibernaculum.

This project is one big experiment, and with experiments we always expect to learn and adapt. In the fall of 2023, our speakers for bat lures were on the ground. In fall 2024, we placed the speakers higher off the ground to better project the calls and hopefully attract more bats to our winter retreats. At the BiodiversityWorks HQ hibernaculum, we broadcast calls from our roof, and at the Batz Carlton we placed the speaker on a balcony above the site. We changed the detectors and microphones inside the hibernacula to different models to see if we can get cleaner acoustic recordings from inside, and we added an extra camera to the BWorks HQ hibernaculum to be sure we don’t miss photographing a bat exiting or entering. This is the last year of our grant funding, but these hibernacula will be available for bats forever. As the housing market shifts and we slowly or rapidly lose the basement/crawl spaces that these bats use as hibernacula, we hope that they will be attracted to and occupy these safe spaces where we know they can survive and thrive amidst the white-nose syndrome crisis.

Literature Cited

Dowling, Z. R., & O’Dell, D. I. (2018). Bat use of an island off the coast of Massachusetts. Northeastern Naturalist, 25(3), 362-382.

Hoff, S., Pendergast, C., Johnson, L., Olson, E., O’Dell, D., Dowling, Z. R., Gorman, K.M., Herzog, C., & Turner, W. C. (2024). Seasonal roost characteristics and fall behavior of coastal populations of Northern Myotis (Myotis septentrionalis). Journal of Mammalogy, 105(2), 277-288.

Liz Olson

Liz Olson

I'm a wildlife biologist and the Asst. Director of BiodiversityWorks on the island of Martha's Vineyard, MA. I have a bachelor's degree in wildlife management from the University of New Hampshire and earned my M.S. in Conservation Biology from Antioch University New England studying the activity patterns of coastal river otters on the island using camera traps.

Get Our eNews Delivered to Your Inbox

We email a monthly newsletter with updates on our projects and programs, as well opportunities to learn online and in-person.

Get Notified for New Posts

Would you like to receive email notifications when we publish a new post?


 

Shopping cart0
There are no products in the cart!
0